13 Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance – Best Rates

Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance

Michigan’s auto insurance rules are among the most complicated in the country. This is due to Michigan’s no-fault insurance rules, which mandate particular coverages and prohibit drivers from filing claims against the insurance companies of other drivers in the event of an accident.

Because of the numerous rules and necessary coverages, Michigan auto insurance is significantly more expensive than the national average. However, if you search around for vehicle insurance and examine some of the best companies, you may be able to obtain excellent inexpensive Michigan car insurance. this article reviews cheap car insurance companies as well as their insurance discounts 

What Are The Factors Influencing Car Insurance Quotes in Michigan

The cost of auto insurance in Michigan is determined by several criteria that are governed by the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services. It is then up to each insurance provider to offer discounts and alter vehicle insurance prices based on criteria such as:

  • Your driving history
  • Your age, educational level, gender,  credit score and marital status are all important factors.
  • Your current location
  • Previous car insurance minimum coverage
  • How many miles do you travel?
  • How long have you been driving?
  • What is your coverage limit?
  • Year, manufacture, and model of the vehicle

Michigan No-Fault Laws

Michigan is one of almost a dozen states that mandate some kind of “no-fault” auto insurance. In a no-fault state, your vehicle insurance covers your medical bills as well as other out-of-pocket damages in the case of an auto accident, regardless of who caused the incident. The no-fault insurance legislation in Michigan, on the other hand, is one of the most convoluted rates for drivers.

Michigan works under a true no-fault system: That means you and your insurance company are responsible for all losses and expenses in the event of an accident, regardless of how the auto accident occurs. Instead, your deductible and other pre-insurance fees will vary based on whom law enforcement deems to be at fault.

It is uncommon to file a claim against another person’s insurance; as a result of these rules, your insurance will cover the majority of or all losses and injuries in the case of an accident. This implies that you will rarely (if ever) submit a claim against another person’s insurance and that you will very certainly be denied compensation for “pain and suffering” or other losses stemming from the accident.

PIP (Personal Injury Protection)

When you or your passengers are harmed in a vehicle accident, personal injury protection (PIP) insurance pays for your medical costs and lost income. In most states, PIP is optional. However, due to the no-fault statute, Michigan requires all motorists to have PIP minimum coverage which made insurance expensive.

Property protection insurance (PPI)

This is a kind of liability coverage that is needed in Michigan for automobile owners. It offers up to $1 million in coverage to assist pay costs if you inadvertently damage another Michigan resident’s property while in the state using your car. To get license plates in Michigan, drivers must have property protection insurance.

Minimum Car Insurance Requirements

Because Michigan is a no-fault state, vehicle insurance has numerous special restrictions. Before you can evaluate who has the best auto insurance in Michigan for you, you should be reasonably confident in your understanding of needed minimum coverage. The following are the basic minimums auto insurance requirements in Michigan:

Insurance TypeRequired Coverage Amount
Property Protection$1,000,000
Uninsured/Underinsured motorist coverageOptional
Bodily injury liability$20,000 per person and $40,000 per accident
Personal injury protection$500,000
Collision and comprehensive coverageOptional
Property damage liability$10,000 per accident

Penalties for Non – insured Motorists in Michigan

Though Michigan does not have an automatic system to monitor uninsured drivers, all automobile owners are required to submit evidence of insurance when renewing vehicle registrations and license plates on an annual basis. Furthermore, all Michigan drivers are required to keep evidence of insurance in their cars at all times.

If you are unable to show proof of insurance to a police officer in Michigan, you may face the following penalties:

  • Suspension of license
  • Vehicle registration and license plate non-renewal
  • A $50 fine as well as other legal expenses

What You Should Know About Michigan Insurance Cheapest Coverage

  • Michigan became one of just 12 states in the country to have no-fault auto insurance reform in 1973. This is one of the main reasons Michigan auto insurance is so exorbitant. The cost of insurance is expensive in Michigan because the state provides lifetime medical coverage to Michigan drivers who are wounded in accidents.
  • The disadvantage of this level of auto insurance coverage is that Michigan is prone to insurance fraud. The auto policies reform bill, which was passed into law in May 2019, aims to cut rates and establish limitations on medical care expenses.
  • While minimum coverage is sometimes the cheapest option, most insurance specialists recommend that you acquire greater liability limits if you can afford them so that you are financially covered in the event of a large loss.
  • The amount you pay for auto insurance coverage is influenced by your driving habits, driving record, clean record minimum coverage limits, and claims history.
  • Because not all vehicle insurers will issue coverage for high-risk drivers, your options for cheap car insurance in Michigan may be limited.
  • Michigan Auto Insurance Laws Minimum Coverage Requirement Liability for Motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person / $100,000 per accident;  Liability for property damage: $10,000; Personal injury protection is $250,000 for the majority of drivers;  $1,000,000 in property protection insurance. Uninsured motorist coverage is not needed. If you’re found driving without at least the bare minimum of vehicle insurance in Michigan, you might face a slew of fines.
  • Damage to your car is covered by broad collision insurance regardless of who is judged to be at fault.

What Is No-Fault Insurance?

If you have no-fault insurance in Michigan, it means that your insurance company will pay for your medical care regardless of who is at blame in an accident. According to WalletHub Michigan, the bar for bringing a lawsuit after an accident in Michigan includes “severe damage, permanent deformity, or death.”

13 Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance – Best Rates

RankCompanyAverage rate monthly
1Secura Insurance$104.22
5Hastings Mutual Insurance Co$198.56
6Farm Bureau Ins of MI$203.09
7Auto-Owners Insurance Co$215.91
8MEEMIC Insurance Company$219.09
10Pioneer State Mutual Co$240.99
13GMAC Insurance Group$260.33

SECURA Insurance Companies

SECURA Insurance Companies is a cheap auto insurance company that operates in 12 states, including Wisconsin, North Dakota, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Minnesota, Arizona, Colorado, Missouri, and Michigan since 1990. They provide flexible, customizable solutions for your business, house, vehicle, farm, agribusiness, and nonprofit as a property-casualty insurance firm. SECURA Insurance’s purpose is to empower independent agents and safeguard their clients by providing superior minimum coverage and cheap auto insurance quotes. As the first on our list, SECURRA is the cheapest option you can imagine

SECURA Insurance Companies average rate is $104.20 per month

Metropolitan Life Companies (MetLife Worldwide)

MetLife businesses are a global innovator and acknowledged leader in protection planning, retirement and savings products throughout the world, with over 153 years of expertise and cheap auto insurance. Through organic expansion, acquisitions, joint ventures, and other collaborations, they have built a significant presence in more than 40 markets worldwide. MetLife firms provide life, accident and health insurance, retirement and savings products through agents, third-party distributors such as banks and brokers, and direct marketing channels across the world. MetLife offers one of the cheapest rates in Michigan.

MetLife Insurance offers car insurance at an average cost of $113.37 per month


Since 1922, USAA has been supporting military men and their families. It all started when 25 Army officers agreed to insure each other’s automobiles. With its diverse collection of financial services firms, USAA now serves millions of members, including cheap car insurance coverage. You may only become a member of USAA if you are a current or former military member, or the spouse of a military member. Children of military personnel may also join USAA. When looking for insurance, if you are an eligible driver for USAA vehicle insurance, it should be at the top of your list as it offers the lowest rates to military men.

USAA Insurance offers car insurance at an average cost of $122.73 per month

Chubb Insurance

Chubb is a major commercial services insurer in the United States with a cheaper auto insurance rate. It provides auto insurance policies for people and companies with classic automobiles and other vehicles in 54 countries and territories across the world. It offers pre-claim restoration, accident repair, and covered loss services. Furthermore, it provides the rental refund, rental damage reimbursement, worldwide rental, and roadside assistance. The car’s value is guaranteed before a covered loss with comprehensive coverage.

Chubb often serves higher-priced automobiles. The Chubb Mobile Estimate App makes calculating damages and settling claims simple and quick. You may also use the app to pay bills and check your ID cards. Many vehicle insurance companies do not offer the variety of coverage options and insurance packages that Chubb does. Its programs are primarily aimed at high-net-worth individuals who can afford premium services, and the website does not mention pricing, discounts, or special offers.

Chubb offers insurance for cars at an average cost of $166.07 per month

Hastings Mutual Insurance Co

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company serves a local Midwest customer that appreciates a community-based provider. That personal touch is reflected in the company’s client satisfaction ratings; call Hastings Mutual Insurance Company for a quotation if you want a cheap car insurance options provider with good customer service and local agents at an affordable rate.

Hastings Mutual Insurance Co offers a car insurance rate of $198.56 monthly

Farm Bureau Insurance

Farm Bureau Michigan is a member of the American Farm Bureau Federation, which is a network of organizations that offers average auto insurance premium throughout the United States. Michigan’s bureau, headquartered in Lansing, only provides the cheapest car insurance quotes to individuals who live and work in Michigan, thus it naturally has a smaller customer pool than other major auto insurance companies. It should be emphasized that to be eligible for Farm Bureau insurance, you must be a Farm Bureau member. This includes insurance for antique cars as well as insurance for your mobile home and motorbikes at a cheap rate.

Farm Bureau offers car insurance at an average rate of $203.09 monthly

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

Auto-Owners Insurance Company provides coverage to a far broader range of clients than just car owners. Through independent agents in 26 states, the business provides choices for insurance coverage. People who require several insurance policies may benefit from the ease and benefits that come with combining them with Auto-Owners, which offers a wide range of coverage choices. Auto-Owners provide all of the standard coverage’s, like roadside assistance, and collision and comprehensive insurance.

Auto-Owners Insurance offers services at an average rate of $215.94 monthly 

MeeMic Insurance Company

This is one of the cheapest insurance companies with over 70 years of expertise in the insurance market. It provides a variety of coverage auto insurance options with a cheaper car insurance rate. Meemic provides 24/7 claims reporting as well as quick auto insurance claim resolution, as well as a variety of discounts. Meemic only serves teachers, educators, and associated staff employees from public or charter schools, as well as private or parochial schools and colleges/universities. 

MeeMic Insurance Company offers insurance for an average rate of $219.09 monthly

Safeco Insurance

Since 1923, Safeco has been serving clients. Safeco, a subsidiary of Liberty Mutual, provides a wide range of insurance products, including vehicle insurance. The Seattle-based insurance firm offers competitive prices on a wide range of coverage choices. It also offers money-saving options through various discounts and bundled coverage. Customers may submit and monitor car claims online with ease.

Safeco offers insurance for an average rate of $235.26 monthly

Pioneer State’s Mutual Insurance 

Pioneer State vehicle insurance policy includes liability coverage that meets Michigan’s state minimum requirement, as well as offering one of the cheapest car insurance rates. They provide three types of nice rates for drivers, collision coverage, as well as a no-fault insurance policy option at an affordable insurance rate. This plan covers new vehicle replacement, travel interruption, preferred site towing, personal property minimum coverage, and other benefits. Motorcycle insurance, as well as RV and travel trailer insurance, are now available from the company.

Pioneer Insurance company average rate is $240.99 monthly 

Travelers Insurance

Travelers may be an excellent vehicle insurance company for consumers that take advantage of some of the business’s various discounts at a cheaper car insurance rate. For example, the IntelliDrive program may lower your annual insurance premiums by up to 20% if you practice safe driving practices, making Travelers a very inexpensive insurance choice. However, if you are reluctant to do your homework, particularly to determine whether you qualify for any discounts or discount program, Travelers is unlikely to be the cheapest alternative.

Travelers auto insurance monthly average rate is $248.74 


Esurance is one of the best auto insurance providers that is well-known for its easy-to-use website, interactive features, and affordable car insurance rate. It’s ideal for those who like to handle their policy, have simple insurance requirements, and prefer to receive prices online. Esurance provides vehicle insurance in 43 states and homes insurance in 31 of them.

Esurance Insurance company average rate is $258.91 monthly

GMAC Insurance Group

GMAC stands out from the rest as one of the cheapest auto insurance companies for a variety of reasons other than the well-known GMAC name. Under the SmartDiscounts and SmartServices banners, its vehicle insurance branch advertises a slew of benefits. These programs provide numerous unique benefits to GMAC auto insurance clients, including GM/GMAC Customer Discounts, Full Policy Payment Discounts, Safe-Driver Discounts, Affinity Discounts, and Low Mileage Discounts, to name a few.

GMAC Insurance average auto insurance rate is $260.33 monthly

Take Away

These car insurance companies in Michigan offer amazing products are unique services; however, the cheapest auto insurance company in Michigan is SECURA Insurance Companies. This company offers amazing programs and affordable coverage rates for both their clients and agents. Because of the closeness of agents to the people, customer complaints are attended to with immediate alacrity. However, if you need Full-Coverage car insurance at an affordable rate, Chubb Insurance is the better option.